Vanilla Honey Roasted Peanut Butter

I love peanut butter! You could probably even say I’m a peanut butter addict. It’s one of my top favorite condiments. And I put it on just about everything. Unfortunately, my all-time favorite brand is one that has a good amount of those partially hydrogenated oils (the bad fats!). 

It’s sad, but true. I’ve even decided to give up buying it because I want to choose healthier products — like the all-natural and no-sugar-added peanut butters. They’re all good in their own way, but none seem to be as good or crave-able as my old stand by. And I miss it. I just love that creamy, silky smooth, slightly sweet peanut butter. It’s almost too good to give up completely.

That is … until now. In honor of National Peanut Month, I decided to give homemade peanut butter a try. And I’m hooked! First, it has to be the easiest recipe I’ve ever made. It’s completely customizable to your desired flavors. And, it ends up with such a creamy and smooth texture, you’ll never miss the old jarred variety.

My recipe for homemade peanut butter is taken over the top with the addition of a vanilla bean and touch of honey. The peanut butter has such a nice floral and sweet flavor. It’s very unique and I think you’ll love it!  

Vanilla Honey Roasted Peanut Butter

Recipe developed by Maria Tadic, RD

Yields about 1-1 ½ cups of peanut butter

2 cups lightly salted peanuts
¼ cup honey
1 vanilla bean
1-2 teaspoons vegetable oil


  1. Preheat oven to 375 F.
  2. Lay out the peanuts on a sheet pan covered with a silpat or aluminum foil coated with non stick cooking spray.
  3. Drizzle honey over nuts and toss to cover most of the nuts.
  4. Roast for 10-12 minutes. You’ll start to smell the peanuts and they will be just slightly darker in color.
  5. Immediately place nuts into the bowl of a food processor along with the seeds of the vanilla bean. Process the peanuts for about 7-9 minutes. Scraping down the sides every so often.
  6. Add in the vegetable oil in the last minute or two — this helps ensure the peanut butter's silky smooth texture.

Note: The nuts will first be ground down into what looks like wet sand. Keep processing the peanuts and they will start to turn into a smoother mixture. Process until you reach your desire smoothness — adding the vegetable oil in at the end will help with this process. However, you can leave the oil out if desired.

Maria Tadic, RD on FacebookMaria Tadic, RD on PinterestMaria Tadic, RD on Twitter
Maria Tadic, RD
Maria Tadic, RD, is a registered dietitian currently working in the field of Bariatric Surgery and Nutrition. She lives in Northern Virginia with her husband. She's a foodie, runner, blogger and self proclaimed home chef! Read more from Maria on her blog, Bean A Foodie, or follow her on Twitter, Facebook or Pinterest.